On Monday, a mistrial was declared in the Christopher Deedy murder case after jurors said they could not agree on a verdict.
Former city prosecutor Peter Carlisle believes the two sides should try to find some sort of middle ground.
Carlisle says he was not surprised the jury came back hung in this case, considering how complex the case was and the fact that it was all or nothing.
“I think that they need to talk, they need to back off dramatically from not guilty, and back off significantly from a life sentence with a 20-year sentence without the possibility of parole,” Carlisle said. “The question is should that have been given to them in the first place? Well, considering the verdict, it was over assessed by the prosecution that it was going to be such a solid case, that it was going to be murder in the second degree.”
Carlisle says not offering up something like manslaughter as a lesser offense could mean another mistrial.
- Deedy juror speaks exclusively to KHON2 News
- Former prosecutor says Deedy retrial would not benefit either side
- Elderts family “exhausted” after trial
- Mistrial declared in Deedy murder trial
- Lawyer: Jurors in Deedy murder trial stuck without manslaughter option
- Former prosecutor shares insight as deliberations continue in Deedy murder trial
- Closing arguments wrap up in Deedy murder trial
- Former prosecutor breaks down Deedy’s testimony
- Prosecutors: Deedy could have walked away from the confrontation
- Special agent Deedy explains why he drew his gun
- Special agent accused of murder takes the stand
- Nurse: Special agent did not appear drunk the morning of deadly shooting
- Friend told special agent ‘Let’s just go’ moments before the deadly shooting
- Defense calls first witness to the stand in Deedy murder trial
- Police detective testifies in Deedy murder trial, last prosecution witness
- Friend of victim cross-examined, explains why he didn’t leave
- Deedy’s friend back on the stand, claims he was severely beaten before the shooting
- Deedy’s friend chronicles night of deadly shooting
- Bullet expert takes the stand in Deedy murder trial
- Evidence specialist: Deedy smelled of alcohol hours after deadly shooting
- Former Marine describes threat made before deadly shooting
- Arresting officer, eyewitness testify in Deedy murder trial
- Man in middle of deadly fight didn’t feel threatened
- Prosecutors show surveillance video in Deedy murder trial
- Deedy trial day 2: Victim’s friend gives emotional testimony
- Trial underway for federal agent accused of Waikiki murder